Wednesday, 9 May 2018

The Arguments and the Key Points


In the essays:
Anwar, Dewi Fortuna. (2018). Indonesia’s vision of regional order in East Asia and U.S - China rivalry: continuity and change. Asia Policy, 13(2), 57- 63.

This essay highlights the positive outlook and diplomatic efforts of Indonesia to bring order to the region of Southeast Asia. The essay notes that following the independent until 1966, Indonesia had a sense of threat from Western neo-colonialism, confrontation with Malaysia, and good relationship with China. However, between 1967 and 1990, as one of the founders of ASEAN, Indonesia had stopped relations with China. Anwar, the author, posits that since then Indonesia has had a leading role in bringing order to the region through emphasising on the centrality of ASEAN and rejecting any foreign interventions. To argue this, the essay outlines some key elements of Indonesia’s foreign policy.  

The author highlights Indonesia's policy of rejecting external military bases and any foreign direct intervention in Southeast Asian waters. Indonesia has always been concerned that foreign assistance should be limited to technical support. Anwar asserts that Indonesia had urged on the other countries of the region to assume the primary responsibility for order in Southeast Asia without external intervention. The essay argues that Indonesia has preferred diplomatic solutions rather than military campaigns to resolve confrontations with Malaysia. Indonesia has played a leading role in establishing ASEAN, which is an obstacle to external threats. All these, including Indonesia's effort in regionalism which is beyond ideological and political differences, developed norms and principles that protected the region of becoming the battleground of external powers and turned it into a Zone of Peace. The essay concludes that Indonesia’s efforts led to an inclusive structure consisting of all relevant powers in a balanced way. 
***
Medcalf, Rory. (2019). Australia and China: Understanding the reality check. Australia Journal of International Affairs. 73(2), 109-118.  

In this essay, Rory Medcalf emphasises the importance of Australia’s new security laws and its Indo-Pacific foreign policy, which is based on security-oriented foreign investment. By recounting the causes and consequences of a reality check, the author rejects seven myths in the discourse of Australia-China relations, and outlines Australia's necessities in order to rebalance bilateral relations with China, which is as follows:

The Australian Government should reassure China that Australia seeks a relationship of mutual respect. Medcalf affirms that potential tension will exist for the future, however, the author highlights the importance of the modulation that had previously expressed by ex-Prime Minister Turnbull but rejects any retreat from national security gains. Secondly, Medcalf suggests a close relationship with the Chinese diaspora in Australia to assure that legislation will have no other effect than protection. Thirdly, an inclusive consultative mechanism consisting of business CEOs and the leaders of state and territory governments is advised. The author states that Australia has to legislate against foreign political donations and to stoop assisting China to achieve emerging technologies. For an effective reaction, Australia should advise its American ally on moderating public debates. In the end, Medcalf once again quotes the ex-Prime Minister in which he said the relationship with China is way more important than to be failed with ambiguity.

Tuesday, 8 May 2018

Evaluation of the Brochure from Another Culture


Cu Chi Tunnel’s Brochure

Foreign visitors, tourists, and people of the region are the target audiences of Cu Chi Tunnel’s Brochure (n.d.). Digging the underground tunnel system of more than 70 km long represents the determination of Vietnamese to battle with the foreigners of French and Americans. The brochure conveys this message by using heroic words and images. This includes the compound terms such as “the holy revolutionary base” and “enemy fighting and national unity”. The photographs are also used to emphasise the heroic sense of past war. The map of the tunnels, aligned with the portrait of a young Vietnamese lady, historical monuments, and well-structured constructions are all rhetorically symbolising Vietnam’s revolutionary heroism.  The heading “Ben Douc Martyrs’ Memorable Temple” The expression implies that all those who have been killed during the war were sacrificed their lives for the country. 


Unlike this brochure ‘Alternate Perspectives on the Cu Chi Tunnels’ reports about the Cu Chi tunnels without any heroic sense and provides an impartial narration of the story. This difference can be easily noticed by the use of words and the tone of language used in the two texts about Cu Chi Tunnels. Comparing to the heroic words used in the brochure the visitors use a plain language without any metaphorical expressions and revolutionary vocabulary. The third kind of story is the narration by an Australian visitor who narrates about the tunnel with fear and danger. The camouflage for in this text is described to be “scarcely wide enough for your shoulders” and the text about inside the tunnel as an unpleasant place you need to use a gas mask which has taken many lives. 

Reference:

Cu Chi Tunnel’s Brochure. (n.d.). Retrieved October 20, 2019, from https://www.cuchitunnels.vn/

Tuesday, 13 March 2018

Language and Thoughts


This is an outline of the arguments in the report by Derek Barry (2017) on the North West Star about Robert Carl Katter’s interview with Sky News, where Robert has objected on gays and said homosexuals people have “stolen” the word gay, ‘which used to mean happy’. The outlines listed here also signifies the relationship between language and thought which are exemplified within the words and the way they are used in this report.
1.     First of all, the report uses the word ‘gay’ in its title with the meaning which is under dispute in the article. Although the writer of the report has disagreed that the primary meaning of the word gay is ‘happy’, but he uses it intentionally and sarcastically, and this sarcasm reveals the relation of language and the position of the article at the very beginning.
2.     There is almost no word that is completely devoid of connotation meaning. The writer uses the word ‘angry’ to explain the state of Robert during the interview.  It is a negative description and shows that Robert does not feel comfortable discussing the issue. It implicitly says that he is angry as he cannot argue his idea.
3.     The relation between the language that Robert uses and his idea can be easily noticed when he talks about ‘gay’ and ‘beauty’. Referring to Alexander Pope’s poem, Robert argues that the word ‘gay’ “it was the most beautiful word in the English language.” It can easily be understood that in Robert’s thought the whole group of gay people are not beautiful. Otherwise, he should not have complained about the correct use of the word.
4.     Robert uses the words “marriage’ and ‘freedom’ in a provocative way to warn others of the spread of homosexuality. Although he not saying that literally, his language clearly reveals his thoughts. 

Reference:

Barry, D. (2017, August 24). Bob Katter is not gay about gays. The North West Star. Retrieved from https://www.northweststar.com.au/story/4878399/bob-katter-is-not-gay-about-gays/